The inspection is over and the score is lower than you hoped. Maybe it has dropped from where it was. Maybe it is the first rating since you took over, and it is not one you want on the door.
What do you do now? And how do you make sure it doesn’t happen again, when you’re not even sure what went wrong?
If the catering side is becoming a headache, you’re not alone. A low food hygiene rating feels personal, and it often lands when you’re already stretched. The good news is that it can be fixed, and there is a clear order to do it in.
By the end of this article, you’ll know what to do after a low food hygiene rating, step by step.
You’ll know your official options, and how to find the real cause so the next visit goes better.
We’ll start with what to do this week. Then we’ll cover the three official options and how to find what is actually going wrong. We’ll finish with Safer Food, Better Business and how to explain the plan to whoever signs off spend.
Key takeaways
- Read the inspection report carefully before you decide anything. It tells you why the score was given.
- There are three official options: an appeal, a right to reply and a request for a re-visit. Each has its own rules.
- An appeal has a time limit, so decide quickly whether you think the rating is wrong.
- Fixing the problems on the list is only half the job. Finding why they happened is what stops them coming back.
- A clear, costed plan makes it easier to get the support you need from the person who approves spend.
In this article
- Start with the report, not the panic
- Your three official options, and their time limits
- Find out what is actually going wrong
- Where Safer Food, Better Business fits
- Make the plan easy to sign off
- When to bring in an extra pair of hands
Start with the report, not the panic
The first few days after a low rating are when rushed decisions get made. Someone gets blamed, a new form gets printed, or money gets spent on the wrong thing. Take a breath and start with the inspection report. The officer will normally explain what they found and what needs to change. That report is your most useful document right now.
Read it with your kitchen lead, not alone. Go through each point and sort it into two piles. One is what you can fix this week. The other is what needs money, time or a question answered.
Bring the issue as it is. You don’t need to have the answer yet. You need a clear list of what was found, so you can decide what to do next.
Your three official options, and their time limits
The Food Hygiene Rating Scheme gives businesses three safeguards. The rules below are from the Food Standards Agency’s guidance for Wales. England and Northern Ireland use similar safeguards, but the details can differ, so check the guidance for your nation before you act.
1. Appeal, if you think the rating is wrong
An appeal is for when you believe the rating doesn’t match what the officer found. In Wales, you must appeal within 21 days of being notified about your food hygiene rating. That period includes weekends and public holidays.
You appeal on a standard form, sent to the council’s Lead Officer for Food. You should hear the result within 21 days of the council receiving your appeal.
Only appeal if you have a real reason. If the report is fair, your time is better spent on fixing the problems.
2. Right to reply, to give your side
A right to reply lets you explain what has happened since the inspection, or why things were as they were on the day. It can be published alongside your rating online.
In Wales, there is no deadline for a right to reply. You can send one at any time up until your next inspection. You don’t have to use a form. Mark it clearly as a right to reply and send it to the officer who inspected you.
Keep it factual and calm. A reply that is offensive, inaccurate or off the point won’t be accepted, and you’ll be asked to change it.
3. Request a re-visit, once you’ve made improvements
A re-visit is a fresh inspection to re-rate your business after you’ve put things right. In Wales, there is no deadline to ask for one, but you can’t choose when it happens.
You ask on a standard form and include evidence of the improvements, such as receipts or photos. Any appeal must be settled first. Your current rating sticker must be on display, and the officer must be able to get in.
The re-visit will be made within three months of your written request. There is a charge, and you may need to pay it in advance.
Don’t rush this one. Asking for a re-visit before the real problems are fixed can leave you with the same score, and the cost of another visit.
Find out what is actually going wrong
This is the step that often gets skipped. People work through the officer’s list, tick each item off and hope for the best.
The list tells you what was wrong on the day. It doesn’t always tell you why. If the cause is still there, the same problems tend to come back.
A catering problem rarely sits in one place. When we look at a low rating, we look across the whole operation.
Staff and training on the day
Do people know what good looks like, and do they have time to do it? A team that is short-staffed or rushed will cut corners, even if they’ve been trained. This is rarely about blame. It is usually about how the shift is set up.
Daily routines and checks
Are cleaning, temperature checks and stock rotation part of the normal day, or something that happens when there’s time? Routines that rely on one person tend to slip when that person is off.
Paperwork and records
Inspectors look at records as well as the kitchen. Are your food safety procedures written down, up to date and actually followed? Records that are filled in all at once at the end of the week are easy to spot.
The kitchen itself
Some problems come from the space: worn surfaces, poor storage, equipment that needs repair or a layout that makes good practice hard. These often need money, so they belong in your plan with a clear reason.
Your catering contractor, if you have one
If a contractor runs your catering, the rating is still on your door. Check what your contract says about food safety, who is responsible for what, and how problems get reported to you. Often, contractor issues come down to unclear responsibilities rather than bad intentions.
Once you can see the cause, the fix gets much clearer. You’ll know what to change, who owns it and what it will cost.
Where Safer Food, Better Business fits
Safer Food, Better Business is the Food Standards Agency’s pack to help smaller food businesses put food safety procedures in place and keep records. Many kitchens use it as the backbone of their paperwork.
It works well when it is part of the daily routine. It works less well when it sits on a shelf and gets filled in before an inspection. If your report mentioned records or procedures, check whether your pack matches how your kitchen really works today.
Larger or more complex operations may need their own food safety system, built around their menu and processes. If you’re not sure which you need, that is a good question to ask before your re-visit.
Make the plan easy to sign off
Often the person dealing with the rating isn’t the person who approves the spend. That might be an owner, a manager, a board or a finance lead.
They will want to know what went wrong and what it will take to put right. A short written plan answers that and saves a lot of back and forth.
Keep it simple. List each problem from the report, the cause you found, the fix, who owns it, the cost if there is one, and the date. Then add when you plan to ask for a re-visit.
A plan like this also helps your team. Everyone can see what is changing and why, instead of feeling blamed for a score.
When to bring in an extra pair of hands
Many managers can work through a report on their own. Outside help is worth it when you can’t see the cause, or the same problems keep coming back. It also helps when you don’t have time to look at it properly.
That is what our EHO Review is for. We look at your report and your operation and help you find what is actually going wrong. Then we work through the actions with you to get things back under control.
Questions people ask after a low food hygiene rating
How long do I have to appeal a food hygiene rating?
In Wales, you must appeal within 21 days of being notified about your rating, and that includes weekends and public holidays. England and Northern Ireland have their own guidance, so check the rules for your nation. If you’re unsure, ask your council straight away rather than wait.
Can I get re-inspected quickly?
You can ask for a re-visit at any time once you’ve made improvements. In Wales, the re-visit will be made within three months of your written request, and there is a charge. It is usually better to fix the causes first, so the re-visit gives you the result you want.
Will a right to reply change my rating?
No. A right to reply lets you explain your side, and it can be shown alongside your rating online. The rating itself only changes through an appeal or a re-visit.
Is it the kitchen team’s fault?
Rarely on its own. Most low ratings come from a mix of routines, records, staffing and the space itself. Looking at the whole operation is fairer to your team and more likely to stop the problems coming back.
We use a contractor. Who is responsible?
The rating is for your premises, so it matters to you either way. Check your contract for who owns food safety, records and repairs. If it isn’t clear, that is often part of the problem, and worth sorting before the re-visit.
What does Fig look at in an EHO Review?
We start with your inspection report. Then we look at how the operation really runs: the staff, the routines, the paperwork, the kitchen and any contractor arrangement. You get a clear list of what to change and in what order, and help to put it in place.
Get the next visit right
A low food hygiene rating is stressful, but it isn’t the end of the story. Start with the report. Decide quickly whether to appeal. Use a right to reply if it helps.
Then do the work that makes the difference. Find out what is actually going wrong, fix the causes and ask for a re-visit when you’re ready.
If you’d like a calm, practical view of where to start, request a free 20 minute cost review. You don’t need to know the answer yet. Start with what is happening now.